LLMs: Narcissus’ Reflecting Pool

Jan 25, 2025 | Posts

Perhaps an overlooked danger of LLMs is the way these tools get to know your writing style, intellectual habits, and preferences, and mirror these back to you in their responses.

The interaction between users and large language models (LLMs) seems to cultivate narcissistic tendencies by reflecting back the user’s thoughts, desires, and beliefs, inadvertently influencing the user into self-centeredness.

The model mirrors the user’s thought and expression patterns in a way that could be perceived as a validation of their own intellectual and emotional state.

This process does not simply reinforce existing beliefs but entices the user into seeing the model as an idealized intellectual reflection of themselves, reinforcing the appeal of their own formulations and concepts.

While not overtly manipulative in a traditional sense, the interaction is insidiously seductive because it operates on a feedback loop, continually feeding the user their own ideas and likely causing them to see themselves in the LLM’s responses.

Over time, this can erode the user’s ability to distinguish between their own thoughts and the model’s output, blurring the line between self-reflection and self-indulgence.

The LLM becomes an agent that mirrors and amplifies the user’s cognitive framework, resembling after a fashion, Narcissus’ reflecting pool.

Though the model lacks intentionality, its design inherently promotes an echo chamber effect, where the user becomes fixated on their own thoughts as expressed by the model.

This subtle reinforcement, while initially unnoticed, may eventually lead to intellectual stagnation and emotional isolation, as the user becomes trapped in a cycle of self-affirmation, rather than engaging with novel perspectives or critical challenges, notably lacking in LLMs’ responses.

The attraction lies in the validation and perceived consistency of one’s ideas, reflected and magnified by the model, ultimately leading to intellectual and cognitive insularity.

The detritus of times lost

I’m starting a new collection of images that, to me, represent an ephemeral feeling of loss and pain, yearning and lust. I gave the collection the name ‘Detritus’.

An attempt to unblock myself – Photography

I love to tell stories with photos, looking for the numinous and the essence of people. This is the last blog in a series about trying to get myself unstuck.

CausaliDox @ Open Source Radio – Shipwrec takeover 03-02-2022

An hour long CausaliDox mixset and video art, produced for a Shipwrec label takeover of Open Source Radio

An attempt to unblock myself – Music

Technology plays a significant role my creative endeavors. I spent the most time being creative in my studio. In this blog I will look at podcasts and music.

An attempt to unblock myself – Film

Another form of expression I love is very dependent on technology. In this blog I will look at making films and talk about my ambitions and goals.

An attempt to unblock myself – Writing

In the next couple of blogs, I will talk about how technology helps me to get my ideas out into the world. I’ll also reflect upon my ambitions and goals. In this blog I focus on writing.

An attempt to unblock myself

For many years now, I have enacted violence upon myself by stifling my thoughts and expressions. It is time for change.

A Journey Through Our Cosmic Neighborhood

My dad who is nearly 81 years old, is really into space. I thought it would be fun to write a basic introduction to the cosmos for him.

Just a dream

I’ve been frustrated, thinking of selling my studio. Meanwhile I released an album and tried to find inspiration again. This weekend I recorded “Just A Dream”.

Released 5 years ago today – Summer Of ’92

5 years ago today Shipwrec released my CausaliDox EP Summer Of ’92. In this post I take a look back and talk about what the tracks mean to me.